TL;DR: An electric shower heats cold mains water itself, so it works without any hot water from your boiler but usually gives a gentler flow. A digital shower mixes hot and cold water from your boiler or cylinder electronically, giving a stronger, steadier shower with push-button control, but it needs a hot water supply.
- Electric: needs only a cold mains supply and a dedicated electrical circuit. Flow drops in winter, when the mains water is colder.
- Digital: needs hot and cold supplies, a hidden processor box and a small 3A power supply. Our TED digital showers start at £699.
- A thermostatic mixer shower needs no electrics at all; ours start at £107.
- Combi boiler or unvented cylinder: a digital or thermostatic mixer usually gives the best shower.
- Little or no stored hot water, or a second shower that must work when the boiler is off: an electric shower can make sense.
Electric and digital showers are often confused because both need electricity and both have a control in the shower. In fact they work in completely different ways, and the right one depends on how your home gets its hot water.
We sell digital and thermostatic mixer showers rather than electric showers, but here is an honest comparison so you can choose the right type for your home.
How each one works
An electric shower takes water from the cold mains and heats it as it flows through the unit, using a powerful heating element, typically somewhere between about 7.5kW and 10.5kW. It does not use any hot water from your boiler or cylinder.
A digital shower takes hot water from your boiler or cylinder and cold water from the mains or tank, and mixes them in a processor box hidden in a loft, cupboard or under the bath. The control in the shower only sends a signal to the processor, so the shower wall needs just a data cable and one mixed-water pipe to each outlet.
A thermostatic mixer shower also mixes your hot and cold water, but with a mechanical cartridge in the valve on the wall. It needs no electrics at all.
Electric vs digital vs mixer at a glance
| Electric | Digital | Thermostatic mixer | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heats the water | Yes, itself | No, uses your hot water | No, uses your hot water |
| Needs a hot water supply | No | Yes | Yes |
| Electrics | Dedicated high-power circuit | 3A supply to the processor | None |
| Flow | Gentler; lower in winter | Strong, depends on your system | Strong, depends on your system |
| Outlets | Usually one | Up to three from one control (TED) | One to three, with a diverter |
| Control | On the unit in the shower | Digital dial or remote | Handles on the valve |
| Our range | Not sold | TED, from £699 | From £107 |
Flow and pressure
An electric shower can only heat so much water at a time, so it gives a gentler flow than a mixer shower on a good system. In winter, when the water coming in from the mains is colder, it has to heat it further, so the flow drops or the shower runs cooler.
A digital or thermostatic mixer shower gives the flow your hot water system can deliver. On a combi boiler or unvented cylinder that is usually strong; on a gravity-fed system with a tank in the loft it can be low. All TED digital systems are pump compatible, so a pumped setup can lift a low-pressure shower.
Which suits your hot water system?
- Combi boiler: a digital or thermostatic mixer shower uses the combi's hot water directly and usually gives a better shower than an electric one. Check the combi can supply the flow you want, especially for a large drencher head.
- Unvented cylinder: mains pressure hot water suits a digital or mixer shower with a big head very well.
- Gravity-fed system: a mixer shower works but can be weak. A pump-compatible digital shower, or a pump with a mixer, gives more flow.
- Little or no stored hot water, or an extra shower that needs to work when the boiler is off: this is where an electric shower makes sense.
Our shower heads guide explains which head size suits your water pressure.
Installation
- Electric showers need a dedicated circuit from the consumer unit, sized for the shower's power rating, installed by a qualified electrician.
- Digital showers need the processor fitted somewhere accessible, a 3A supply from a plug or fused spur, and a qualified plumber and electrician. Because only a data cable and one pipe run to the shower, they suit stud walls and are good for retrofitting an existing bathroom.
- Thermostatic mixer showers are plumbing only, with the valve fitted on or into the wall.
Running costs
An electric shower uses a lot of power while it runs: a 9.5kW shower running for 10 minutes uses about 1.6kWh of electricity. A digital or mixer shower uses hot water heated by your boiler or cylinder, so its cost depends on how you heat your water; the digital processor itself uses very little power. Which is cheaper depends on your energy prices and how long you shower.
Our digital showers
TED digital showers start at 38°C, can be set from 12 to 45°C, and shut off completely if the water or power supply fails.
- TED TOGO: a digital dial on a large round, square, oval or ring backplate, running two or three outlets, in seven finishes including brushed brass and matt black. From £1,075, or as a complete shower kit.
- TED VENN: two or three outlets with a wireless remote, from £1,320.
- TED WYSE: a traditional-style digital shower for a period bathroom, from £1,250.
- TED CUBA: a single-outlet black glass control, £699.
Prefer no electrics in the shower at all? Our thermostatic shower sets and valves start at £107 with the Plana range, and our concealed thermostatic shower valves guide explains the options. Our guide to digital vs thermostatic showers compares those two in detail.
Prices include VAT and were correct at the time of writing. Check the product page for the current price.